Culture Has Always Been Measurable. The Infrastructure to Measure It Has Simply Never Existed Until Now.

Instill CEO and four-time CHRO Dean Carter on why passive behavioral signal collection makes engagement surveys structurally obsolete — and why the five performance culture vitals are the data layer HR has needed since GAAP was invented for finance.

Curtis Forbes

·

8 min read

Fifty years of research confirms the connection between culture and business outcomes with enough consistency that any organization still treating culture as a soft, unmeasurable dimension of workplace management is not operating in good faith with the evidence. High-trust cultures outperform low-trust ones on every meaningful financial metric. Psychological safety is the strongest predictor of team performance at scale. None of this is disputed. What has been disputed — or more precisely what has been used as justification for not investing seriously in culture measurement — is the claim that culture cannot be measured with the rigor and continuity that financial performance can be measured. That claim is no longer accurate.

The engagement survey, the 360 feedback instrument, and the consultant-led culture audit have each served as placeholders for a measurement architecture that the market has not been able to build until now. They are episodic tools in a domain where the signal is continuous, self-reported instruments in a domain where the signal is behavioral. Every limitation of these legacy instruments is a design problem that passive behavioral signal collection — running through the conversations where work actually happens — is architecturally positioned to solve.

Dean Carter spent more than two decades as a four-time Chief Human Resources Officer before stepping into the CEO seat at Instill, a performance culture intelligence platform that measures the behavioral signals flowing through team meetings in real time, without a single survey. His perspective is grounded not in a product pitch but in the practitioner’s experience of wanting this capability at Patagonia, Sears, Fossil, and Guild — and not being able to build it because the technology did not exist. It exists now.

Passive signal collection makes surveys structurally obsolete — not incrementally better

The argument Dean makes against the engagement survey is not that surveys lack value in principle. It is that they are structurally mismatched to the domain they are supposed to measure. Culture, defined as how people actually treat each other when they are working together, is a continuous behavioral phenomenon. A survey that captures how people say they feel about that phenomenon once or twice a year — under conditions where the respondent knows who will read the results — is not measuring culture. It is measuring a social performance of opinions about culture.

The 360 feedback instrument is, if anything, a more acute version of the same structural problem. Every person giving the feedback knows it is identifiable regardless of nominal anonymity, because the recipient will immediately begin trying to reverse-engineer who said what. The resulting data is a set of socially managed signals that reflect the relationship dynamics between the giver and the receiver more reliably than the actual behavioral patterns under evaluation.

“It is objective completely. It is intelligent completely. It has no vested interest in your success or failure. It just wants you to know what’s going on in the room.”

Dean Carter — on passive signal vs. 360 feedback

The connection to MustardHub’s behavioral workforce intelligence infrastructure is in what both platforms share as a foundational design commitment: the signal worth collecting is the behavioral signal that runs continuously through the actual work — not the signal that can be extracted through periodic, socially loaded self-report instruments. The category is not engagement measurement. It is behavioral intelligence, and the distinction is not semantic.

What would your own workforce say right now?

Live insights on your workforce in two minutes.

Get my workforce read

The annual performance review is destructive agriculture

The regenerative agriculture analogy Dean borrowed from Patagonia is the most clarifying framework available for understanding why the annual performance review is not just an unpopular HR tool but a structurally destructive one. Conventional agriculture extracts maximum yield from the soil in a single season, returns nothing, and leaves the growing environment more depleted than before the crop was planted. The annual performance review follows the same extractive logic: it asks for maximum output, rates what it gets, returns feedback that neuroscience research has shown takes six months to recover from psychologically — and then expects the same or higher output in the next cycle.

“Work should be the same thing that we treat the environment. What I believe is that work should be restorative. For what I put into my work, I believe the company puts back equal or greater value to my life.”

The regenerative alternative measures the behavioral conditions that determine whether performance is developing in the right direction continuously — and returns that information to the people who can act on it, in a form that supports their agency rather than their defensiveness. The MustardHub post-hire blind spot framework captures the same regenerative logic applied to the employment lifecycle: the period between hire and the next formal HR event is precisely where current measurement infrastructure provides no visibility.

The five performance culture vitals are the conditions most likely to drive high performance — full stop

The five vitals Instill measures — trust, psychological safety, innovation, inclusion, and resilience to burnout — were not selected because they represent the values a progressive workplace should aspire to. They were selected because fifty years of research on the behavioral determinants of high-performing teams identifies these five conditions as the ones with the strongest empirical connection to the business outcomes organizations actually care about.

VITAL 01

Trust

VITAL 02

Psych safety

VITAL 03

Innovation

VITAL 04

Inclusion

VITAL 05

Resilience

The decision to measure at the team level rather than the individual level reflects the same research base. The conditions that determine whether a team produces outcomes greater than the sum of its members are relational conditions, not individual skill conditions — and relational conditions can only be measured in the interactions between people. An individual engagement score tells you how a person feels about their job. A team-level behavioral score tells you about the environment in which the work is actually being done.

“Imagine 10,000 times a week: 10,000 people are a little bit better next week than they were last week. That’s what Instill does.”

Dean Carter — on continuous behavioral feedback

The MustardHub stability pattern data and the Instill performance culture vitals address adjacent layers of the same behavioral intelligence architecture. Understanding that a specific team is showing attrition risk patterns is more actionable when it is paired with understanding that the same team is showing low psychological safety scores, because the combination points toward a root cause rather than a lagging indicator.

Behavioral intelligence is not a surveillance tool — by design

The surveillance concern that surrounds any behavioral signal collection tool is legitimate and worth addressing directly rather than defensively. The worry is not just a privacy argument — it is a data quality argument: a workforce that believes its behavioral signal is being used against it will manage that signal, and managed signal is not behavioral intelligence.

The design choices that keep signal authentic

  1. Individual scores are visible only to the person being scored — not to their manager or anyone else in the organization.
  2. Data is de-identified at the team level for any team smaller than five people, preventing inference about individuals.
  3. Feedback is framed in growth-mindset language — a signal to improve contribution, not a record of behavioral failure.

Dean’s own inclusion score is the clearest illustration of why these design principles matter. He received a low score, and his first response was resistance: the system must be wrong. When he read the specific behavioral observation — that he had focused disproportionately on the loudest voices in a meeting while two quieter participants went largely unengaged — he had the information required to change the behavior.

“No one would have told me that. The next meeting I did, I asked why she was quiet. She lives in Ukraine, in Kyiv. So she’s thinking about safety, not psychological safety. I have a better team and I make better decisions when I start with her first.”

When HR data has the same quality as financial data, the people function finally gets its influence

The analogy Dean draws between GAAP and the absence of equivalent standards for people data is the most structurally important argument in the conversation for anyone building in the HR technology space. Financial reporting has had generally accepted accounting principles since the 1920s, creating a standardized data language that allows boards, investors, and leadership teams to make decisions about financial performance with a shared understanding of what the numbers mean. The people function has had turnover rates, headcount, and engagement scores — none of which connect to business outcomes with that rigor.

Dean’s vision of a future where fifty percent of CEOs have HR experience is not a diversity aspiration. It is a prediction about what happens when the people function finally has data that connects its decisions to business outcomes with the same clarity that finance and marketing have had for decades.

“Once we get a really good piece of data in terms of understanding what drives outcomes in business… then the job becomes the most powerful job and the most important job to lead companies in the future.”

Dean Carter — on the HR-to-CEO pathway

What HR tech operators should do with this

Build passive signal collection before your next survey cycle

Identify the conversations in your platform’s scope where behavioral signal could be collected without self-report, and begin building the architecture that captures what people do rather than what they say they think.

Reframe your value proposition around restoration, not extraction

Audit whether the data your platform produces primarily serves the person being measured or the person managing them — and return behavioral intelligence to the people generating the signal.

Ground your culture metrics in the research base, not values aspiration

Track the behavioral conditions research connects to performance outcomes — trust, psychological safety, inclusion, resilience — and build the ROI argument that makes culture a CFO conversation.

Design surveillance prevention before you build signal collection

Individual privacy protections, de-identification thresholds, and growth-mindset framing belong in the product architecture before deployment — not as a retrofit in response to adoption resistance.

Position your platform as the infrastructure that closes the GAAP gap

Build your roadmap and sales narrative around the specific business outcomes your behavioral signal connects to, in the language boards already use to make investment decisions.

MUSTARDHUB
VOICES
Behind The Build
Dean Carter: Culture Is a Signal. Now We Can Finally Read It.
JUN 25 · MUSTARDHUB VOICES: BEHIND THE BUILD
Save on Spotify

DC

About the guest

Dean Carter — CEO, Instill

Four-time Chief Human Resources Officer at Patagonia, Sears, Fossil, and Guild. Independent board director and number-one bestselling author recognized for his regenerative approaches to HR and AI in the workplace. Follow his work on LinkedIn or at instill.ai.

Measure your culture in real time, without another survey.

Employers save $3,000+ per employee by catching preventable exits early.

Get my workforce read

Curtis Forbes

About the author

Founder & CEO, MustardHub

Estimate your turnover cost

Live insights on your workforce in two minutes. 5 questions, no credit card.

See my $ risk
Stay in the signal.
Original research and fireside chats on behavioral workforce intelligence, in your inbox.
Subscribe