The Power of Employee Recognition Programs: Driving Engagement and Business Value

Published on July 17, 2023 by MustardHub Admin

Employee recognition programs have proven to be highly effective in driving employee engagement, as numerous studies indicate. While these programs may appear to be small gestures, they hold significant value for employees. In fact, investing in incentives and rewards can yield substantial cost savings, with the potential to save tens of thousands of dollars. Furthermore, a well-executed employee recognition program can enhance motivation, performance, and even foster innovation among employees. In today’s volatile labor market, where retaining talent is crucial, the impact of employee recognition cannot be underestimated.

However, there are two important factors to consider for employee recognition efforts to be effective. First, these efforts should be distributed equitably, ensuring that recognition is based on individual contributions rather than being uniformly provided to all employees. Failure to do so can result in hollow and thoughtless recognition that not only wastes resources but can also have a negative impact on employee morale. While most companies make some effort towards employee recognition, the approach varies. Some offer words of affirmation, others provide bonuses, and some even reward valued employees with gift cards for their hard work.

To gain insights into the impact of employee recognition programs, reviewing studies and research articles published over the last dozen years reveal that employee recognition programs do make a difference, but their effectiveness depends on various factors, such as the type of incentive, industry, and rationale behind the recognition. If you’re advocating for an employee recognition program in your organization, there is substantial evidence to support its value. Conversely, if you’re considering cutting back on such a program, it may be wise to reconsider.

Factors To Consider In Recognition Programs

Performance-Tied Incentives: Financial incentives are most effective when directly tied to individual or team performance.

Equitable vs. Equal Distribution: Equitably-distributed incentives, based on individual performance, lead to better employee performance, while equally-distributed incentives that are unrelated to performance do not yield the same positive outcomes.

Industry Impact: Financial incentives are particularly effective in increasing engagement among employees in the financial sector and also those working hourly or as independent contractors, but have limited impact in the public sectors. 

Tailored Incentives: Highly skilled and knowledgeable employees prefer bonuses and commissions, while lower-skilled employees tend to value profit-sharing and group bonuses.

Simplicity is Key: Adopting both individual and collective incentive schemes does not yield better performance compared to choosing one or the other. In fact, implementing both types of schemes can have a negative impact on performance.

Employee Recognition: Business Value and Cost Savings

Replacing valuable employees goes beyond the time and effort invested by recruitment teams and hiring managers. It also incurs significant financial losses for companies. Companies spend upwards of 200% of an employee’s salary in overall losses when they must be replaced. These avoidable expenses quickly accumulate when multiple employees leave, highlighting the importance of employee retention efforts. This further emphasizes the importance of programs that mitigate turnover and enhance company culture as a destination for worker happiness. 

In short, financial incentives play a vital role in Human Resource Management (HRM) by fulfilling employees’ basic needs, attracting and retaining top talent, improving performance, and demonstrating appreciation towards individuals and teams. However, the effectiveness of financial incentives depends on their direct tie to performance. 

Employee Engagement: Industry Impact and Incentive Effectiveness

Employee engagement directly influences turnover rates, as emotionally committed employees are less likely to leave their jobs. A 2020 study showed that highly engaged employees had up to 43% lower turnover rates compared to lower-engaged workers. However, the effectiveness of financial incentives in driving employee engagement varies across industries. 

Additionally, researchers have found that equitably distributed rewards play a critical role in driving employee engagement. Alongside social support and opportunities for learning and development, financial incentives and employee recognition efforts have the potential to meaningfully boost engagement. Commissions, special performance incentives for field staff, holiday gifts, and other financial incentives have been shown to increase engagement. 

Incentives Tied to Achievement: Driving Employee Performance

While financial incentives may not be strongly correlated with increased employee engagement, they have a clear positive impact on employee performance. An analysis of over a hundred studies found that team-based financial incentives significantly improve employee performance. The study demonstrated the importance of rewarding employees as teams to motivate them further, emphasizing that equitably distributed rewards lead to higher performance compared to equally distributed rewards. Equitably distributed rewards are fair and based on individual or team performance, while equally distributed rewards are the same for all teams, regardless of performance.

Furthermore, our review of the literature revealed that team-based incentives not only improve individual performance but also enhance team performance by promoting collaboration. However, it is important to keep incentive structures simple and straightforward. An overly complex incentive scheme can have a negative impact on innovation and performance.

The Impact of Financial Incentives on Retention, Innovation, Engagement, and Performance

With plenty of research to support, it is evident that financial incentives can play a significant role in employee retention, innovation, engagement, and performance at both individual and team levels. Financial incentives come in various forms, including competitive pay, commissions, bonuses, and holiday gifts. When considering budget allocation for employee recognition programs, it is important to recognize the impact they can have as part of broader employee retention initiatives. 

Ready to implement a rewards and recognition program, but unsure where to start? We can walk you through the process, every step of the way. Download our free 4-step Guide To Solving Your Recruitment and Retention Woes and schedule a demo to see how MustardHub can put those headaches behind you.


Problems With Recruiting & Retention?

Don't miss out on talent. Enrich your culture and eliminate turnover with MustardHub.
Download our 4-step Guide To Solving Your Recruiting & Retention Woes.

Get the guide

See What Makes MustardHub Different

We’re small business friendly and are built to accommodate organizations with a flexible workforce like independent contractors, part-timers, gig workers, and more. With core values that include inclusivity and flexibility, companies can add an unlimited amount of premium or standard (free) members, with no minimum!

MustardBrokers Icon

In addition to health, wellness, and lifestyle benefits, MustardHub also has an exclusive Health Advisor partner to help all workers, regardless of employment classification, get access to group-style health insurance benefits and supplemental group health coverage.

MustardBrokers Icon

MustardHub boasts 75-80% lower upfront costs than competitors, making it an ideal solution for small businesses, associations, and organizations that rely on small teams, contractors or flexible workforces. Rest easy knowing that you can reduce tax liabilities, and there are no mandatory yearly commitments, contracts, or required minimum contributions.

Have Questions? Reach out.

Enter your email address and our team will contact you as soon as possible.

Scroll to Top